Norway defends its oil with creativity

Some people may be surprised to learn that Norway’s Arctic is “different” from other Arctic areas, thus making oil drilling and production less risky. Or that Norwegian oil production is much “cleaner” and “safer” than it is elsewhere. That’s what increasingly creative government ministers are claiming, though, and they won some support on Monday from international experts.

Is Norway’s Arctic, like here around Svalbard, different enough from other areas of the Arctic that oil drilling and production should be okay? That’s what one Norwegian minister is now suggesting, as the country tries to justify its oil and gas industry balance its conflicting roles as an oil nation and environmental advocate - writes

“We’re in an age of irony,” said Mary Evelyn Tucker, an expert on religion and ecology at Yale University. She’s among rainforest advocates who are in Oslo this week for a meeting on rainforest preservation that’s billed as “unprecedented,” and rather creative itself.

Tucker spoke at a press briefing just before the Norwegian government started hosting leaders of various religions and spiritual traditions for what amount to unusual climate talks in Oslo. The goal, according to organizers including the United Nations Development Program, is to discuss “the spiritual and ethical responsibility they share to protect rainforests” and thus help fight climate change. Lars Løvold, executive director of Norway’s own Rainforest Foundation, called it an effort “to unite forces” to help preserve the most unique eco- and life-support systems on earth.

Both the former Labour Party-led Norwegian government and the current one led by the Conservatives have spent billions over the past decade on rainforest preservation. Government officials also claim they’re committed to fighting climate change. At the same time, however, Norway continues to generate and export millions of tons of the carbon emissions believed responsible for causing climate change through the country’s large and, until recently, hugely profitable oil and gas industry.

That paradox has been pointed up for years in Norway and is now gaining increasing international attention, most recently in the New York Times. It’s prompting Norwegian officials on both the left and the right to get more creative in their defense of Norway’s onward expansion of its fossil fuels industry, which is now rapidly expanding into the Arctic as well.

Climate and Environment Minister Vidar Helgesen has had a tough year, from dealing with angry farmers who want to shoot wolves to seeing his latest plans for cutting climate emissions in Norway blasted on all sides. On Monday he was hosting a meeting on rainforest preservation, at a time when the Norwegian government is keen to keep expanding its oil industry. The conflicting roles have not gone unnoticed. PHOTO:

“The Norwegian Arctic is different from other parts of the Arctic,” Norway’s current Climate and Environment Minister Vidar Helgesen from the Conservatives, told after the press briefing on the rainforest meeting Monday morning. “That’s because of the Gulf Stream, which they don’t have off Canada or the US.” Helgesen suggested the Gulf Stream can make Norway’s offshore areas less vulnerable to the risks of pollution, “because of how the waters flow and such.” Norwegian officials also claim the new exploration blocs being offered to oil companies are far enough away from rapidly melting polar ice.

Helgesen and Prime Minister Erna Solberg also insist that it’s important for Norway to keep producing gas because it’s an important alternative to coal and because Europe needs politially stable flows of energy. Helgesen also noted that use of natural gas in the US has helped reduce carbon emissions.

Helgesen, his government colleagues in the Oil Ministry and his predecessors from the Labour Party further claim that Norway produces its oil and gas in a far more environmentally friendly manner, and under stricter controls, than producers in other countries. While that’s been a subject of much debate, Helgesen lauded Norway’s biggest company, state-controlled Statoil, for putting more resources into alternative energy ventures such as wind power.

It should be noted, however, that both the former Labour-led government and the current Conservative coalition did nothing to stop Statoil from venturing into its ill-fated oil sands project in Alberta, Canada, which has been blasted as among the most environmentally unfriendly projects in the world. After suffering heavy losses on its oil sands involvement Statoil finally pulled out last year.

“We like to say that they went into the oil sands during the Labour government and got out during ours,” Helgesen said with a smile, but stressed that neither government should take credit or blame because “we have a policy as owners not to micro-manage the companies.” He was proud, however, that Statoil has been praised as among the “best” oil companies in the world from an environmental standpoint.

Mary Evelyn Tucker, a noted scholar on religion and ecology from Yale University, claims that “we’re in an age of irony,” and that Norway retains international respect on climate issues despite its oil industry. Others argue that Norway’s insistence on expanding its oil industry has hurt its climate and environmental credibility. At left, Antonio Donato Nobre, a rainforest expert from Brazil. 

Helgesen’s guests in Oslo on Monday were all highly appreciative of Norway’s rainforest initiatives and financial support over the years, even though rainforests keep continue to shrink at “a perilous rate.” Helgesen insisted that rainforest preservation remains “really high” on his government’s agenda, and this week’s meeting is aimed “to bring a moral and spiritual commitment” to it as well.

“The urgency can’t be overstated,” Helgesen said, adding that the Paris Agreement “is doomed” if deforestation doesn’t stop. He acknowledged that despite Norway’s huge investment in rainforest preservation, “we’re still coming up short.” He’s hoping that Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, Daoist and Jewish leaders meeting in Oslo will mobilize perservation efforts and “bring a spiritual imperative” to the issue.

Tucker of Yale University hopes so too, stressing that the world needs the cooperation and coordination of religious groups. It’s hoped they can convince their followers about the importance of preserving rainforests instead of chopping them down in the quest for economic gain in a world that meeting organizers described as “besieged by growing global demand for commodities.”

In the end, it often comes down to money and the risk that when profits talk, principles walk. Just as Norway’s economy has been fueled by oil resouces, communities from Brazil to Indonesia can be tempted by economic gain from the rainforests’ wood.

Antonio Donato Nobre, senior researcher at the National Institute of Amozonian Research, maintained that indigenous populations have a clearer sense of the sacredness of the rainforests as “something you don’t mess with.” He also suggested that rainforest preservation can be even more important than cutting back on oil production: “20 percent of greenhouse warming is caused by carbon emissions. 60- to 80 percent is caused by water vapor. Why is no one talking about the water vapor?”

‘A transition moment’

The panel even noted that Norway’s oil industry has generated so much money that it’s enabled funding of, for example, the rainforest initiatives and even this week’s meeting. “The respect for Norway is enormous,” Tucker claimed, despite its oil industry that can offset carbon emissions elsewhere. She stressed that the world and its climate are going through huge transition: “This is a transition moment,” she claimed.

Helgesen stressed that it’s “no secret” that Norway is an oil- and gas-producing country, and will remain so “for quite some time to come.” It’s a question of how long oil and gas will be commodities in demand, and how long oil companies will think it’s profitable to explore for new resources and produce them. “Our role as politicians,” told later, is to set the framework.”

While Norway makes offshore fields available to oil companies, Helgesen noted that government policies aim to make their product as unappealing as possible to Norwegians themselves. “Who’s trying most,” he queried, to discourage driving, for example, and electrify transport? “Norway!”

Helegesen also noted how Norway has been actively working towards restructuring its economy, so that it’s less reliant on oil and gas. The country is indeed in the midst of its own transition. In the meantime, though, the oil will flow while efforts continue to keep the rainforests from being chopped down.

Read other news on the city site of Oslo.

Norway oil
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
2 views in february
I recommend
No recommendations yet


Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Euronext operates stock exchanges in Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels, Dublin and Lisbon. In a statement, the operator said it had approached the board of directors of the Oslo Stock Exchange (Oslo Bors VPS) to seek its support for a tender offer of 625 million euros for all outstanding shares in the bourse. "Euronext strongly believes that Oslo Bors VPS' unique strategic and competitive positioning, including a global leading position in seafood derivatives and...
The Abortion Act is one of the most controversial issues during the Government negotiations that started on Hadeland yesterday. NTB has talked to several who were on the «red» side in the struggle for the Christian Democrats’ choice of direction. That ended up with a «blue» victory as most are aware. Not least because of Deputy Leader Kjell Ingolf Ropstad singled out that it presented a «historic opportunity» to make changes to the Abortion Act’s section 2...
A Morocco prosecutor on Sunday presented to an anti-terror judge 15 people suspected of links to the murder of two Scandinavian women in the Atlas Mountains, Rabat's attorney general said. The prosecution asked that the suspects be investigated for "setting up a gang to prepare and commit terrorist acts", "premeditated attacks on life" and "advocating for terrorism", the attorney general said. Seven other detainees will be referred to the prosecution in th...
Lower Norwegian King Crab quotas in 2019 The total Norwegian quota for male King Crabs has been set at 1400 tonnes for 2019. This is a decrease of 350 tonnes from 2018. The Ministry of Fisheries simultaneously warns of tighter control of the industry.   – In recent years we have had a very high degree of harvesting of King Crab. Now the researchers say that if this continues, it will lead to a collapse of the stock. That will not happen. We will continue t...
Dreary news from around the world As Christmas peace descends on those fortunate to live in a peaceful corner of Tellus, it is business as usual, out in the ”real” world. Death toll rises after an attack on Government buildings in Kabul 43 people have been killed following an attack on Government offices in Kabul, Afghanistan on Christmas Eve, the authorities state. At least ten people are injured. Most people killed are employees of the Ministry of Labour...
Heavy winds, avalanche and landslide hazards and slippery roads create problems in several places in Norway on Christmas day. – Drive extremely cautiously, the police urges.   Slippery roads, closed Mountain crossings and bad weather In Voss, one of several areas where, according to the Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate (NVE), there is a considerable landslide hazard on Christmas Day, a two-cubic meter block of ice fell on the E16 at Evanger...
Since 1999, the average American has become heavier and shorter according to a state health study. By 2015, the average height Americans around the country were 175.4 centimetres, two millimetres shorter than at the start of the study in 1999. American women were also two millimetres shorter. The study also shows that American men and women have become around three kilograms heavier on average since 1999. The average American woman now weighs 77 kilograms,...
PFU believes that iTromsø, Dagsavisen and Harstad Tidende have violated good press coverage in their writing surrounding sexual harassment allegations against former Progress Party Youth (FpU) Deputy Leader, Kristian Eilertsen. The cases ended with that Eilertsen received a warning from the Progress Party’s organisation committee, without being deprived of office nor imposed with other sanctions. Eilertsen reacted to the coverage of the matter in iTromsø,...
The European Union on Tuesday published further contingency plans for a "no-deal" Brexit, piling pressure Prime Minister Theresa May by warning that Britons will lose a host of travel rights from recognition of driving licences to lower credit card fees and no mobile roaming charges. The European Commission, the bloc's executive arm, said that, while it is working hard for a deal, it must prepare for "all outcomes" and "contingency measures in narrowly def...