Oslo's car ban sounded simple enough. Then the backlash began

When Oslo decided to be the first European city to ban cars from its centre, businesses protested. So the city did the next best thing: it banned parking

One day late last summer, in Frogner, a central neighbourhood of Oslo, Nils Sandberg received a note - reports theguardian.

“It simply stated that shortly, parking spaces in these streets would disappear and bicycle lanes would be built,” says Sandberg. He spoke to neighbours, and learned they had all received the same note. “This came as a total surprise and shock.”

More people own cars in Frogner than in most other parts of Oslo – 38% household ownership, compared to roughly 30% in other central neighbourhoods – and the idea of losing all their parking space to bike lanes did not appeal.

“We are not against cycling,” says Sandberg, who now leads a campaign to save the parking spaces. “We do, however, believe that cycling is not the only reason for the chosen routes – it is definitely also meant to force a maximum number of cars out.”

This was, in truth, exactly the plan. When a progressive political alliance took power over Oslo’s city council in October 2015, they had made one of their first priorities a greener and more liveable environment in the city. With an almost 30% increase in population expected by 2040, the Norwegian capital was worried about its carbon footprint.

It wasted no time, selling off its coal investments, creating a renewable district heating system and firmly committing to slashing greenhouse gas emissions (to 95% of 1990 levels) by 2030.

It’s too much and too soon. Shop owners and visitors need time to adapt

Beathe Radby Schieldrop

The biggest bugbear, however, was transport, which accounts for 61% of the city’s CO2 emissions – a full 39% of it coming from private cars.

Yet the council presided over a city that already boasted the world’s highest proportion of electric vehicles, and ran a third of its bus fleet on fossil fuel alternatives. What more could be done?

One big idea: ban cars from the city centre. If pulled off, the plan would see Oslo become the first major European city to have a permanent, complete no-car-zone, racing ahead of a long list of cities seeking to do the same.

The proposed car-free zone seemed like a good place to start. It focused on Ring 1, the innermost ring road of Oslo’s three motorways, a 1.7km sq area that is home to around 1,000 people of whom 88.1% do not own a car. Just 7% commute by car, with 64% doing so on public transport, 22% on foot and 7% by bike. Banning all cars – petrol, diesel, hybrid or electric – seemed like an easy win.

“The city becomes more enjoyable and more accessible without car traffic,” read the coalition’s declaration in October 2015.

There was just one problem.

“A Berlin Wall against motorists,” declared one conservative party politician. “Car owners feel ‘bullied’ in Oslo”, blared an English-language news site.

The biggest backlash, however, came from the city’s trade association, the Oslo Handelsstands Forening (OHF). It said it feared the plans would create a “dead town”, and a “poorer city [with] less life”.

“Many speciality shops depend on people coming from far away, who may not bother to come if they have a complex travel route,” says OHF communications manager Beathe Radby Schieldrop, explaining their opposition. “People tend to shop where it is easy to shop.”

The plan was simply too revolutionary, the group maintains. “It’s too much and too soon,” Schieldrop says. “Shop owners and visitors need time to adapt.”

If you can’t ban cars...

So, after almost a year of back and forth, Oslo’s council changed tack.

“We modified some of the plans after discussing things with shopkeepers,” says Lan Marie Nguyen Berg, a Green party politician and the city’s vice mayor for environment and transport. “Not because we think that more cars means more shoppers. But because we need to ensure that the transport of goods to shops can be both good for city life and shopkeepers.

“We chose a gradual model, rather than one where you remove everything and then fill it in [with alternatives] after.”

The council changed its stated ambition to have a car-free city centre. It now wants the “fewest possible vehicles”. Drivers are by no means off the hook. “The goal is that people with cars will feel like they’re visitors, rather than owning the streets,” says Berg. “We’ll make it difficult for people to want to drive or get around by car.”

Even electric vehicles (previously allowed in bus lanes) will feel the heat, Berg says. “The goal is that there should be no more space for cars, and an electric vehicle still takes up space,” she says. “By 2030, I hope that all cars in the city will be electric – [but] we won’t have space for them all.”

The council’s clever solution? Rather than banning cars, it would ban parking – all 650 on-street parking spots. In their place, “we’ll put up installations and create public spaces,” says Berg, referring to six pilot areas. “Some will be playgrounds or cultural events, or [contain] benches or bike parking – or other things you can fill the space with when you don’t have 1,200 kilograms of glass and steel.”

If it’s necessary we’ll create a car ban. But we’ll see if we can do it through more gentle and natural initiatives

Lan Marie Nguyen Berg

Oslo’s transformation will be rolled out in three phases. In stage one, all on-street parking within Ring 1 will be removed, as well as some parking in surrounding areas deemed to be “in conflict with bike development”. Car parks in and around the central zone will stay, but many other on-street parking spaces will be freed up for alternative uses.

Stage two, in 2018, will see the pedestrian network extended, and close several streets to private traffic; shared space will be introduced, and 40 miles of bike lanes built.

The council’s final year will be one of reflection. “We’ll see if the removal of parking and the restrictions on driving through the city centre will be enough,” says Berg. “If it’s necessary to get to our goal, then we’ll create a car ban. But, until 2019, we’ll see if we can do it through more gentle and natural initiatives.”

‘We’re not against cycling but …’

The opposition from car owners, like Sandberg in Frogner – which is not itself in the city centre but is nevertheless seeing its parking spaces reduced – has thrown a wrench into the plans, but the idea of extending the cycle network is not actually new. In 1977, the council planned a fully connected cycle grid. Little has materialised, however: from 2005-2015, just one mile of bike lane was constructed on average every year. The number of cyclists has grown, but in the absence of dedicated cycling infrastructure, serious injuries are becoming more common.

“There are lots of nice bike paths to get to the centre, but as soon as you reach it, pfff, gone,” says Liv Jorun Andenes, an information officer for the City of Oslo bicycle office. “But that’s where all the traffic, the tram tracks and trucks are. So that’s where you really need good solutions.”

Oslo’s cycle modal share – the proportion of trips taken by bike – sits at 8.3%, which the council wants to increase to 25% by 2025. It drops to 3% in the winter, although the council’s efforts to clear snow from bike lanes has helped. “The bicycle still hasn’t become a natural part of life for people here,” says Andenes. “A lot of people regard it as a seasonal thing when the sun is shining … But it is starting to change.”

For those put off by Oslo’s hills, the council released 5 million Norwegian krone (£465,000) to help citizens purchase electic bikes. This year, they’re targeting families with another money pot for cargo bikes.

Bicycles will also replace delivery vans in a new pilot project: starting this month, a container in the Aker Brygge neighbourhood will function as a micro-terminal for freight transport – the first of its kind in Norway. Goods will be dropped at the terminal, and distributed throughout the city by electric bicycle. The plan is a collaboration between the public roads administration, Oslo municipality and DHL.

And for every resident who hates the idea of banning cars (or parking), there are several who welcome it. In Grünerløkka, where around 185 parking spots are being removed, local Marius Åslund is looking forward to the coming changes. “I’ve lived in both Copenhagen and Amsterdam and I’m used to cycling everywhere. Now living in Oslo I’ve only ridden my bike a handful of times,” he says. “If they’re going to build safe bike lanes that mean I don’t have to ride with trams and cars, then I’d definitely consider cycling to work.”

Even the shopkeeper’s association is happier. “We’ve participated in numerous meetings and have come up with the idea that the best thing would be to carefully change things street by street,” says Schieldrop. “Make every street a success, and then celebrate the transformation. Success is totally dependent on the participation of shops and cafes – no one will sit on a bench in an empty street.”

Guardian Cities is dedicating a week to exploring the future of cycling in cities around the world. Explore our coverage here and follow us on Facebook. Will you be taking our challenge to have conversation with a fellow cycle commuter? Tell us about it here or on Twitter or Instagram using #cycleconvo
Read other news on the city site of Oslo.

theguardian
carban Oslo electricvehicles car-freecitycentre
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
1 view in february
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Society
Euronext operates stock exchanges in Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels, Dublin and Lisbon. In a statement, the operator said it had approached the board of directors of the Oslo Stock Exchange (Oslo Bors VPS) to seek its support for a tender offer of 625 million euros for all outstanding shares in the bourse. "Euronext strongly believes that Oslo Bors VPS' unique strategic and competitive positioning, including a global leading position in seafood derivatives and...
Society
The Abortion Act is one of the most controversial issues during the Government negotiations that started on Hadeland yesterday. NTB has talked to several who were on the «red» side in the struggle for the Christian Democrats’ choice of direction. That ended up with a «blue» victory as most are aware. Not least because of Deputy Leader Kjell Ingolf Ropstad singled out that it presented a «historic opportunity» to make changes to the Abortion Act’s section 2...
Society
A Morocco prosecutor on Sunday presented to an anti-terror judge 15 people suspected of links to the murder of two Scandinavian women in the Atlas Mountains, Rabat's attorney general said. The prosecution asked that the suspects be investigated for "setting up a gang to prepare and commit terrorist acts", "premeditated attacks on life" and "advocating for terrorism", the attorney general said. Seven other detainees will be referred to the prosecution in th...
Society
Lower Norwegian King Crab quotas in 2019 The total Norwegian quota for male King Crabs has been set at 1400 tonnes for 2019. This is a decrease of 350 tonnes from 2018. The Ministry of Fisheries simultaneously warns of tighter control of the industry.   – In recent years we have had a very high degree of harvesting of King Crab. Now the researchers say that if this continues, it will lead to a collapse of the stock. That will not happen. We will continue t...
Society
Dreary news from around the world As Christmas peace descends on those fortunate to live in a peaceful corner of Tellus, it is business as usual, out in the ”real” world. Death toll rises after an attack on Government buildings in Kabul 43 people have been killed following an attack on Government offices in Kabul, Afghanistan on Christmas Eve, the authorities state. At least ten people are injured. Most people killed are employees of the Ministry of Labour...
Society
Heavy winds, avalanche and landslide hazards and slippery roads create problems in several places in Norway on Christmas day. – Drive extremely cautiously, the police urges.   Slippery roads, closed Mountain crossings and bad weather In Voss, one of several areas where, according to the Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate (NVE), there is a considerable landslide hazard on Christmas Day, a two-cubic meter block of ice fell on the E16 at Evanger...
Society
Since 1999, the average American has become heavier and shorter according to a state health study. By 2015, the average height Americans around the country were 175.4 centimetres, two millimetres shorter than at the start of the study in 1999. American women were also two millimetres shorter. The study also shows that American men and women have become around three kilograms heavier on average since 1999. The average American woman now weighs 77 kilograms,...
Society
PFU believes that iTromsø, Dagsavisen and Harstad Tidende have violated good press coverage in their writing surrounding sexual harassment allegations against former Progress Party Youth (FpU) Deputy Leader, Kristian Eilertsen. The cases ended with that Eilertsen received a warning from the Progress Party’s organisation committee, without being deprived of office nor imposed with other sanctions. Eilertsen reacted to the coverage of the matter in iTromsø,...
Society
The European Union on Tuesday published further contingency plans for a "no-deal" Brexit, piling pressure Prime Minister Theresa May by warning that Britons will lose a host of travel rights from recognition of driving licences to lower credit card fees and no mobile roaming charges. The European Commission, the bloc's executive arm, said that, while it is working hard for a deal, it must prepare for "all outcomes" and "contingency measures in narrowly def...